500 Book Reviews 80% Reviews Published Professional Reader

Saturday, April 18, 2026

Whose Body in the Library (Lighthouse Library Mystery #13), by Eva Gates

 Publication June 9, 2026

Lucy McNeil is beginning her new job as library director and new hire, Nichelle Gilchrest has arrived to fill her usual spot. Nichelle is excited, having upended her old life to move here but her first day doesn't go as planned. As she opens the doors of the lighthouse library to welcome her first day library users, she finds a dead body on the steps. Lucy arrives at about the same time and knows the routine, so it isn't as disruptive as it might be, but there's another issue. Nichelle sees a startling resemblance in the dead man to her father who disappeared many years ago and has been thought dead. There's also a new detective in town, Detective Rhonda Thomas, who is very by the book and regularly tells Nichelle not to get involved. I bet you can guess how much good that did her, huh?

Long time series fans, don't despair. Lucy is still there, just playing a diminished, backup role. Let's face it. She's now the mother of very young twins and sleuthing isn't exactly on her priority list. She's there for Nichelle (yes, her name has a Star Trek connection) but really isn't involved in the investigation. Nichelle's initial interest is really as much on what brought the man she suspects might be her father to her new doorstep only to be murdered as on who did it. Oh, of course, that changes when she learns who the chief suspect is. Nope, not telling. You'll have to read the book. I'm not going to give away any more of the plot but it's a solid one that does offer an occasional chapter from Lucy's viewpoint. The usual cast of characters isn't showcased as much as long time fans might wisht, well, except for, sigh, the one character that has always grated on me while I must still admit she adds a certain touch of quirkiness to the plots. Even Lucy still hasn't quite sorted out how best to deal with her, which I'm sure will add a few laughs as the series continues with Nichelle as the focus. Oh, and least I forget, Charles the library cat is definitely on hand. 

Bottom line, Eva Gates had me wondering when I read the initial news about Lucy stepping back but this one works nicely. I liked Nichelle, even when she was making some very rookie sleuth mistakes. Hey, they all have to start somewhere. As always, the lighthouse itself is practically a character and Gates descriptions of its history and the surrounding area are excellent. While we didn't get to meet all of Nichelle's family this go-round, we've been at least introduced and I'm sure it's no accident that she, like Lucy, has twins, albeit grown daughters. It was also subtle but I think we may come to like the new detective, too, although I'm sure Rhonda and Nichelle will butt heads more than a few times in the process although the likable, but retired Sam Watson is still around. Thanks #CrookedLaneBooks for introducing me initially to Lucy and allowing me this early peek at the arrival of Nichelle to take over some of the work load, probably both work and sleuthing. I do hope Lucy will find time for not just get some sleep but to pop in-and-out as the series continues. We do want to get to know Isaac and Lucas, too, hint, hint. Grin. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Whose Body in the Library (Lighthouse Library Mystery #13), by Eva Gates

 Publication June 9, 2026 Lucy McNeil is beginning her new job as library director and new hire, Nichelle Gilchrest has arrived to fill her ...