Publication May 12, 2026
I honestly think my first introduction to George Armstrong Custer and the Battle of the Little Big Horn was due to my horse focus. I recall badgering my grandparents to take me to the drive in, yes, I'm that old, to see the Disney movie "Comanche". I don't recall being bothered at all by the violence of the battle, probably due to Disney magic, though certainly filled in the gaps as the years passed. This one definitely doesn't spare us the details of the battles, including the mutilation of bodies...by both sides, mind you. So, be prepared. There are some tough scenes included but it's well worth the read to get an honest, informed idea of all that went before Custer was turned into a mythic hero. There's even a bit about how his widow contributed to that, I might add, not to mention that Comanche the horse gets some space, too.
Needless to say, I'm not going to even try to summarize. This is definitely not a lighthearted read that will leave you admiring Custer. It will also give you the reasons behind the title choice, a choice made by the United States government that had little love for the natives slowing their westward movement. How ironic to read about Native leaders even being honored by a visit to the White House and meeting the President, not to mention a visit to NYC, but their tribes still being hunted down and massacred. It's a complex, tragic story. There are no heroes or villains here, just flawed humans on both sides. The author has pulled from the massive works of other authors here, too, and managed to pull it together in an easily readable, albeit frequently uncomfortable read. I did grin that he managed to work in a descendant of Alexander Hamilton, btw, though you're going to have to read the book to discover who and how. You're sure to catch more than a few other historically significant names, too.
What I particularly enjoyed was how Clavin blended the stories of not just Custer, but Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse. You get their backgrounds, some history leading up to the battle that changed history forever, and their demise. Of course, military leaders get their moment, including a rather detailed sense of how Major Reno handled himself throughout and after the battle. Oddly enough, though many of the scenes and history depicted are violent, the book manages to avoid falling into being a sad, depressing read by making readers think. Clavin doesn't waste his time trying to point fingers or blame one side or the other. Instead, he leaves it up to his readers to digest the info and come to their own conclusions. It's a lengthy read for some, I'm sure, but well worth it if you have any interest in history and the many ups and downs that created the current nation, one even now dealing with its treatment of Native Americans.
Bottom line, it's been quite a while since I've delved into the Custer legend, so I have to admit to being fuzzy what I knew and didn't know going into this book but I found it intriguing. Organized into six different "acts" covering various phases, it opens with a prologue on Custer's Washita attack, setting the stage for what follows. Although in theory the Native Americans won a great victory at the Little Big Horn, it was also an ending for them, all of which is covered. My thanks to #StMartin'sPress and #NetGalley for allowing me this early look at a piece of history I've always found sadly intriguing. It was great to refresh my memories and perhaps be shown another viewpoint at time. And, of course, I was glad to see Comanche's days of being an icon of sorts and what happened to him given coverage. Rather took me full circle back to those days of anxiously waiting for the movie to begin at the drive-in.
No comments:
Post a Comment