Available Dec. 8, 2026 First published December 31, 1963
It's been a long time since I revisited The Giving Tree. If memory serves, my first reaction was sadness and confusion. What was going on? Why was the boy being so needy? Was he bad? Selfish? And, what about the Giving Tree? What were we supposed to take away from her unending unselfishness? Was there no limit to her giving and him taking? Can one's need for love ultimately be destructive? While I'm sure others about me were equally bemused, most fell into following the teacher of the moment's lead and the prevailing interpretation. I probably just came away from the moments, however, just figuring I wasn't smart enough to get it yet.
Today, equally baffled as to how to interpret the poem, it's obvious not only wasn't I getting any smarter or better at interpretation, neither were many of the reviewers over the years. Yep, gotta admit it. I went cruising through old reviews looking for insight. What I got were everything from hatred to the boy and, equally amazing, the same disdain for the Giving Tree. Others, of course, praise it but even then the interpretations of what is really being said vary drastically. Perhaps that was Shel Silverstein's point. That everyone be allowed to see things via their own world view and come to different conclusions rather than be lead to a nice, neat, definitive conclusion. Then again, who knows?
While I still don't have a definitive interpretation, even one I can cling to long, perhaps the fact this short, seemingly simple poem has kept me and countless others wondering speaks of its power. I can certainly hypothesize several possible interpretations, such as mankind savaging Mother Nature and giving nothing in return while she continues to sustain us (based on current world headlines of doom and destruction), but it could also be seen as a simple parable of a mother's love being unending, even when the child doesn't appreciate it. Most likely neither is the true point but, well, it has engaged my brain cells more than a few times over the years, gotta admit. Thanks #HarperAudio for allowing me this early listen to this classic read by Silverstein himself, allowing me to revisit an old, ongoing mystery. Seriously, if you check the multitude of reviews, you'll see few agree. If this is a new one to you, be prepared to ponder countless possibilities and perhaps, like me, still not come to any conclusion. Dang it, Shel Silverstein made me think Grin.

No comments:
Post a Comment