Publication July 1, 2025
When Andy met Tara....and Laurie.
What a delight to go back in time to meet a younger but no less snarky Andy Carpenter in his first true murder defense trial. Even better, we get to spend some time getting to know his father, a renowned prosecutor, Nelson Carpenter. I liked their easy, trusting relationship where, even knowing his father wished Andy hadn't moved to the defense table, he's there 100% for Andy. Nelson even turns out to love dogs, noting that the only reason they never had a family dog was due to Andy's mother's allergies.
Even as a long time Andy Carpenter fan, going back and meeting Tara for the very first time was also delightful. Never mind Andy walked into the shelter looking for a small dog. Tara had him with their first look. It goes almost without saying that a dog, Tara's then kennel buddy Sonny, was involved in Andy taking the case of Ryan Tierney, Sonny's owner, who has been charged with murder. Blowing up a car kind of murder. Yikes. Sonny is under a legal hold until after the trial, however, and a waver is needed before the shelter can release Sonny to anyone but Ryan. Needless to say, since Andy seems to feel it is only right to keep Tara and her canine friend together, Andy visits the jail to get the waver and finds himself with a client. Thus begins the fun.
As usual, this case if far, far more complicated than the norm. I won't detail the plot further but will hint that it involves, let's see, hit men, shady business practices, potential suspects who keep getting themselves killed, life insurance scams, mob action, federal agents, and....well, you get my drift. Besides the younger Andy, we get our first meeting with investigator extraordinary Laurie Collins and discover Andy has friends himself on the police force, even if he does have to pick up their tab at meals. We also "almost" get to meet Marcus, he of incredible protective skills and that's touching the surface. I say "almost" meet because while Andy doesn't get to meet him in person, Marcus plays a major role in the story. Oh, and I can't forget Sam, Andy's accountant who seems to harbor dreams of being an detective. Andy usually seems to keep him tethered to the computer, which is where Sam's formidable hacking, er, computer research skills usually play a vital role. It's interesting to see how they manage to incorporate Sam's discoveries legally, let's just say. That said, who knew Sam had skills at breaking into cargo trucks?
Bottom line, a fun, entertaining read with lots of laughs and remarkable insight into the courtroom and investigative processes. As always,, I marveled at Andy's then young courtroom skills and ability to use humor, personality, and, yes, snark as weapons for the defense.There's a fine line between pushing too far and irritating the judge and making his point, all of which Andy tip-toes along skillfully. I've told friends occasionally that the reason I know what news people are talking about at times on court cases, you know, all that legal terms, is because I've picked up some legal vocabulary from this series, in fact. Rather amazingly, author Rosenfelt weaves this all together skillfully while sharing the ongoing marriage woes of Andy and then wife Nicole. I admired Rosenfelt's delicate touch with this, even while introducing Laurie. He shows the mutual respect and love Andy and Nicole share, albeit now firmly heading along different paths with different goals. Let's just say, it would have been easy to portray Nicole as a spoiled rich girl but Rosenfelt don't take that shortcut and, instead, presents her as a sympathetic character. Speaking of sympathetic characters, Thanks #StMartin'sPress - #MinotaurBooks for giving me this early spin on the time machine back to meet the younger but already charmingly snarky Andy and some of those who play such a huge role in his status as a reluctant attorney who is always trying to retire.